Perhaps Castleton is just in the wrong league? They are being labeled here as cheap thugs just because they lead the ECAC East in pen mins but in the bigger picture they are nowhere near the most penalized team in the country. They are not even in the top 10 most penalized. This year they were 12th, last year 26th, and the year before that 28th.
It is a style of play. They are a physical team, it does not mean they are dirty or undisciplined. They are being coached to be aggressive, to take advantage of their size, there is nothing wrong with that. It seems to be working for them as they were better than all of the other teams in the interlock but one. Fans from the East better get used to it, because this Castleton team won't be going away any time soon.
Adrian and Stevens Point have been much more penalized than Castleton over the last three years, I don't hear anyone whining about them. Seems to me this line of Castleton bashing is more personal, as in "we don't like you, you didn't deserve a bid, someone threw snow at me" than about what they are really like on the ice.