What's new
USCHO Fan Forum

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

  • The USCHO Fan Forum has migrated to a new plaform, xenForo. Most of the function of the forum should work in familiar ways. Please note that you can switch between light and dark modes by clicking on the gear icon in the upper right of the main menu bar. We are hoping that this new platform will prove to be faster and more reliable. Please feel free to explore its features.

MLB 2018.1: ...And The Nationals Will Not Make It Out of the First Round

Status
Not open for further replies.
Re: MLB 2018.1: ...And The Nationals Will Not Make It Out of the First Round

I'm not sure you're going to believe this, but the Mets may have just batted out of order in the second inning.

With a runner in scoring position. Don't forget that. That's what makes it extra Metsy.
 
Re: MLB 2018.1: ...And The Nationals Will Not Make It Out of the First Round

With a runner in scoring position. Don't forget that. That's what makes it extra Metsy.

Well... not really. We only achieved the runner in scoring position by batting out of order. Remember, the transposition NCFB --> NFCB causes us to bat out of order three times. First when Flores batted after Nimmo (should have been Cabrera). Second when Cabrera batted after Flores (should have been Bruce). Third when Bruce batted after Cabrera (should have been Flores). Bruce is called out for batting out of order. Bruce's PA (taken by Cabrera) is erased. So we never had a man in scoring position under any circumstances.

Let's say Flores had gotten a hit. Then when Cabrera had approached the plate Cincy would have protested. Cabrera would have been called out for batting after Nimmo. Cabrera's actual PA, taken by Flores, would have been erased. Bruce would have come up with two outs. Interestingly, in that situation Bruce is OK to bat because he is considered to be batting after "the legitimate batter" Flores who is considered never to have batted because Cabrera stole his spot. This despite the fact that Flores actually did something and Cabrera did nothing.

I like the rule and I'm pretty sure it makes sense, it's just really difficult at first.
 
Last edited:
Re: MLB 2018.1: ...And The Nationals Will Not Make It Out of the First Round

All you need now is failure to touch a base.
 
Re: MLB 2018.1: ...And The Nationals Will Not Make It Out of the First Round

Giants hitters strike out 55 times in a 4 game sweep by the Phillies.
 
Re: MLB 2018.1: ...And The Nationals Will Not Make It Out of the First Round

So Ian Kinsler, with two outs, turned away from a ball that was inside, didn’t break his wrists, but the bat clearly crossed the plate. Next pitch, homer. Should he have been out?
 
Re: MLB 2018.1: ...And The Nationals Will Not Make It Out of the First Round

So Ian Kinsler, with two outs, turned away from a ball that was inside, didn’t break his wrists, but the bat clearly crossed the plate. Next pitch, homer. Should he have been out?

Crossed the plate? Strike. Crossing is one of TWO qualifications for a strike, as I understand the rules.
 
Re: MLB 2018.1: ...And The Nationals Will Not Make It Out of the First Round

The rule on batters swinging at a pitch or holding up has nothing to do with the bat crossing the plate, or the wrists breaking. Although umps do tend to use those criteria to help decide.

It's was the batters "intent" to swing and hit a pitch. Completely subjective and really impossible for a fan or broadcaster to predict.

I wish they would clear that rule up. Instead they are working on pitch clocks and robots.
 
Re: MLB 2018.1: ...And The Nationals Will Not Make It Out of the First Round

The rule on batters swinging at a pitch or holding up has nothing to do with the bat crossing the plate, or the wrists breaking. Although umps do tend to use those criteria to help decide.

It's was the batters "intent" to swing and hit a pitch.

I had no idea of this. Been watching baseball for 48 seasons and I thought "breaking the plane of the front of the plate" was the actual rule.
 
Re: MLB 2018.1: ...And The Nationals Will Not Make It Out of the First Round

A's bats finally wake up and beat the Yankees 10-5. And Graveman didn't suck. Good day for Oakland.
 
Re: MLB 2018.1: ...And The Nationals Will Not Make It Out of the First Round

I had no idea of this. Been watching baseball for 48 seasons and I thought "breaking the plane of the front of the plate" was the actual rule.

Neither did I.
 
Re: MLB 2018.1: ...And The Nationals Will Not Make It Out of the First Round

From Nick Cafardo's Baseball Notes in today's Globe
From the Bill Chuck files — “The Nationals have struck out six times this season on foul bunts.” . . . Also, “In 1993, the world champion Blue Jays struck out 10-plus times in a game 11 times. This season, the Blue Jays already have twelve games with 10-plus strikeouts. Then again, in 1993 there were 380 10-plus strikeout games, and this season there are already 424 games in which a team whiffed 10-plus times.”
 
Re: MLB 2018.1: ...And The Nationals Will Not Make It Out of the First Round

From Nick Cafardo's Baseball Notes in today's Globe

And yet, the avg runs a team scores this year are 4.48, while in 1993 it was 4.6. Apparently striking out doesn't really change how much you score if your HR per game avg goes from .89 to 1.15. :rolleyes:
 
Re: MLB 2018.1: ...And The Nationals Will Not Make It Out of the First Round

When you think about it, it makes sense. Lose 1/27th of your outs for a chance at a run.
 
Re: MLB 2018.1: ...And The Nationals Will Not Make It Out of the First Round

Well... not really. We only achieved the runner in scoring position by batting out of order. Remember, the transposition NCFB --> NFCB causes us to bat out of order three times. First when Flores batted after Nimmo (should have been Cabrera). Second when Cabrera batted after Flores (should have been Bruce). Third when Bruce batted after Cabrera (should have been Flores). Bruce is called out for batting out of order. Bruce's PA (taken by Cabrera) is erased. So we never had a man in scoring position under any circumstances.

Let's say Flores had gotten a hit. Then when Cabrera had approached the plate Cincy would have protested. Cabrera would have been called out for batting after Nimmo. Cabrera's actual PA, taken by Flores, would have been erased. Bruce would have come up with two outs. Interestingly, in that situation Bruce is OK to bat because he is considered to be batting after "the legitimate batter" Flores who is considered never to have batted because Cabrera stole his spot. This despite the fact that Flores actually did something and Cabrera did nothing.

I like the rule and I'm pretty sure it makes sense, it's just really difficult at first.

< hand in the air >
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top