You aren't doing either. You're just making specious arguments Fishy-style and turning "may" into "must" in order to box out people of all choices except for those of which your narrow argument admits.
Centrists and older women will come out for Hillary because they like her. Liberals and everybody under 40 will come out for Hillary because they hate Drumpf. Nobody knows what the relative size of those two groups will be, but while the former is inelastic the latter is highly elastic and depends in large part on Hillary's surrogates like you not giving them a reason to say, "a pox on both your houses." And unfortunately that is all you've been doing for months.
Conservatives can be brought to the polls by beating them over the head -- due to bad parenting or toilet training or something they react to that. Liberals will turn around and give you a richly deserved "S T F U." So since you seem to be doing everything you can in the service of a strategic vision, change your tone and acknowledge that there are very good reasons for liberals to distrust Hillary and that nonetheless you welcome their support and promise that in the end they won't be dissatisfied with a Clinton presidency.
Or maybe just stop shouting at everybody who doesn't follow your exact set of political preferences and allow them to come to her in their own way.