Not saying this is how it should be, but i think voters have this weird "show us for a couple of years" mentality for freshman who dominate the league like Hutson. Or maybe its because they think these guys will turn pro, and save the bigger awards for the guys that stick around. I'm happy Levi won, but he was better last year, and if you have a bad stretch like that (and i'm NU guy), you are probably not POY. Same thing last year with the Hobey. Levi probably deserved it, McKay had a longer body of work, but not a better season. How do you win the Hobey as a goalie, but not win the Richter?. None of it ever makes sense.
I have nothing against Pandolfo, and congrats to him for winning COY. But if you were picking sides for kickball or hockey, every day of the week you jump at the BU lineup (over pretty much any lineup in the conference). Borek has done a great job getting players to go to Merrimack, doing whatever he has to do to compete in HE. This would have been a good year to have co-COYs.