People always use the word better like there is some absolute benchmark proving that School A is better than School B. Sure, there are all sorts of entities who will rank schools based on a list of selected factors, but when a women's hockey player is looking at colleges, the odds are pretty good that her list of priorities will be at least slightly different. For example, is a university located somewhere where she would like to live for four years? Focusing strictly on education, Colgate has its advantages, but there are areas where it cannot compete with the Big Ten schools. The bigger schools offer more variety in terms of both courses and degree programs. If she wants to study something outside of the 50-some majors she can get at Colgate, then she is less likely to view Colgate as better. If she is not sure of a major, as many aren't, then bigger schools have more options after arrival. Others don't want to attend schools where the enrollment is measured in tens of thousands, period. Each student has her own unique set of criteria, but luckily, between D-I and D-III, she'll have a variety of choices of what school to attend.