I have two themes rolling around in my head this morning. First is the comparison of this team with the those of the immediate past. Two years ago I looked at the roster and felt that there were a few players who had the capability of elevating their game and help make UNH competitive. The one who came to the fore, of course, was Bobby Butler. As mentioned before, through talent and extremely hard work he became one of the best players in college hockey that year. Last year, it was the same, the team needed one or two guys to elevate their games. I felt that Paul Thompson was the guy (more so than DeSimone & Sislo) and sure enough, he had an outstanding season. This year I am still wondering who THE guy is going to be. Our senior forwards all work very hard but I don't see any one of them taking charge and carrying the team on their back like Butler and Thompson did. I guess this is proof positive of what Watcher asserts as the decline in talent at UNH over the last 5-6 years.
This leads me to the larger question as to why this is happening. First, UNH has had somewhat of a problem the last few years getting targeted recruits into school. Reid and White are two prime examples, as well as BC's Gaudreau who was second star last night. I was told that admissions, instead of turning him down, didn't even bother to look at his transcript. This tougher attitude at admissions is puzzling to me because UNH Hockey has always had a graduation rate of well over 90%, with more than a few of their players having outstanding academic records (Flashians, Regan, Butler come to mind). Why is this happening to the signature sport at UNH and what can be done to rectify it? This issue has to be weighing on both Umile and Scarano.
Watcher correctly notes that our talent pool has gotten thinner over the years and, beyond the admissions issue, I wonder if the current state of college hockey will prevent UNH from reversing this trend. The overall pool, for all schools, continues to get thinner with so many top level players opting for Major Juniors. The ones that remain will surely gravitate to the signature programs - UND, Denver, Notre Dame, BC, BU - leaving schools like UNH which have always been what I would call "high second tier" scrambling a bit more to find those diamonds in the rough. UNH has always done a good job of getting those guys and Umile has always done a fantastic job molding them into highly competitive teams, but you have to wonder what it is going to be like in the future. I don't want to be a gloom and doomer because UNH has bounced back in the past. But the landscape for college hockey is so different now - the Big Ten, the National Hockey Conference, Notre Dame joining Hockey East - I just wonder if a school like UNH, which is not cash rich, can continue to compete the way they have in the past.
BTW Watcher, re: your last sentence on Tortorella? I had the same thought.