Re: Prep School Question
...which may be meaningless to how the NCAA interprets it.
I'm not disagreeing with anything anyone has said, especially those that have gone the Prep school route. All I am saying is be careful if you do not have financial need. In addition to families who had true need, we all know kids who have played for free here or there when their parents clearly had zero financial need (usually because they brag about it). You have to be vigilant for your daughter. These teams only care about making their teams better. They don't tell you that it might be an NCAA violation. I never wanted to be in a position where the NCAA told my daughter she was ineligible because she didn't pay hockey fees when I clearly had zero financial need.
This may be much to do about nothing because I have never heard of any female hockey player being declared ineligible from playing DI, but I certainly didn't want my daughter to be the first.
I’m not sure what you mean by “clearly had no financial need” and “didn’t pay hockey fees”. Are you talking about a couple of thousand bucks for a club team or $40k at Ivy Prep? Some prep schools have hockey fees, but many don’t. I certainly agree with your sentiments with regard to some club teams, but I certainly don’t with the reputable prep schools.
At most reputable prep schools, any applicant or returning student who applies for financial aid has to fill out a form that is similar to the form that private colleges require (much more comprehensive than the FAFSA that most public institutions require). Typically, they require you to submit a copy of your tax return. The
schools, not the parents, determine whether the student has financial need, and what percentage of that financial need the available funds can satisfy (that's where some of the games are played). Most parents I know who “brag about getting financial aid when they had no financial need” are bull****ers whose biggest accomplishment in life is that they bullied their son/daughter onto the A team instead of the B team.
With regard specifically to one statement:
These teams only care about making their teams better.
Regarding the reputable prep schools, like the ones HockeyEast33 (edit: or the school and the league that backhand sauce mentioned in an excellent and informative post), I strongly disagree with your statement. The schools have
far more to lose than any individual player has to lose. Most of them have written policies that forbid the giving of athletic scholarships and/or belong to leagues that forbid the giving of athletic scholarships. Their continued success is based on getting alumni into Harvard, not having a great hockey team. If any school was giving athletic scholarships
per se, there’d be a headmaster, a financial aid officer, and a hockey coach looking for jobs, and the prospects for the ex-headmaster and the ex-financial aid office would be pretty bleak.