You're joking, right? We were a bottom tier team the past two seasons, and both Freakouts were so loud you can barley hear the broadcast if you try to rewatch them on RPI TV's YouTube channel. You can barley hear the goal horn on the broadcast because the crowd is so loud. The only other game in the ECAC that comes anywhere close would be Cornell's Cornell vs Harvard game, and while I have not been to a Cornell vs Harvard game and have no interest in going to one, comparing our RPI TV's stream, to the video highlights of Harvard vs. Cornell at Cornell the past few seasons, RPI's Freakout looks much more wild. Granted, it's not the RPI of the 80s that caused the famed NCAA RPI noisemaker rule, but there is a reason that the ECAC promo videos show RPI's Freakout crowd with the rally towels, and I suspect if they need a crowd shot in next years, they will go to Freakout again.
It effects play on ice. 2023, RPI demolishes Yale in the Freakout. It was the only time we beat Yale that season. 2024, Colgate is preforming much better than RPI. RPI in the Freakout outplays Colgate everywhere except the shootout. If I had to guess, the reason why the Colgate player made the mistake to pass, leading to the Hotson 3rd period tying goal to send it to overtime was the environment. 2025, RPI plays their best hockey of the season to win the Freakout.
In general I would agree with you that most games, RPI's atmosphere is not what it should be, and the massive scale of The Field House doesn't necessarily help. That being said, Freakout is the one game that shows what The Field House can do. If the Freakout has no atmosphere, what exactly are you expecting for atmosphere?