NFL 2009 Thread #3: The Quest for Perfection

[SiouxTechie]

Re: NFL 2009 Thread #3: The Quest for Perfection

Is consistent reffing too much to ask for?

Yes.

[Handyman]

Re: NFL 2009 Thread #3: The Quest for Perfection

Now they got the ball back. Big turnover.

Not that big because they can't stop the run or tackle worth a ****.

[thecomicbookguy]

Re: NFL 2009 Thread #3: The Quest for Perfection

Ok, now that is a horse-collar.

[Terrierbyassociation]

Re: NFL 2009 Thread #3: The Quest for Perfection

So, a "horse collar" is now anytime you grab the back of the jersey up near the neck? Isn't it supposed to be hand inside the pads (not even just the jersey), and pulling the guy backwards? Is consistent reffing too much to ask for?

TMQ was the guy who kept asking for the horse collar penalty, but the big problem is refs don't know what a horsecollar penalty even looks like! Any time the hand looks close to going inside the jersey, penalty. One time the guy just put his hand on the collar and tackled the guy. Didn't put his hand inside the jersey, nothing: just a great tackle.

In theory, having the penalty on the books is a great thing, protecting players from dangerous tackles. However, refs were already bad at the judgment calls to begin with and making them make those quick snap analysis of something new? Brutal.

[Terrierbyassociation]

Re: NFL 2009 Thread #3: The Quest for Perfection

That's offensive PI. Just shoved Woodson to the ground.

[mookie1995]

Re: NFL 2009 Thread #3: The Quest for Perfection

That's offensive PI. Just shoved Woodson to the ground.

will you be quiet and let the cards win?!?!?! (i like cards @ saints next week )

[Terrierbyassociation]

Re: NFL 2009 Thread #3: The Quest for Perfection

will you be quiet and let the cards win?!?!?! (i like cards @ saints next week )

No.

And that onside kick was awesome.

[Terrierbyassociation]

Re: NFL 2009 Thread #3: The Quest for Perfection

We got ourselves a game.

Now lets see them onside kick again.

[Terrierbyassociation]

Re: NFL 2009 Thread #3: The Quest for Perfection

Umm, that was a whole mess of holding on that Wells run.

[Terrierbyassociation]

Re: NFL 2009 Thread #3: The Quest for Perfection

Wow, this is like an offensive PI clinic. And a how to tackle a defender into your QB and get it called as a PF against you!

[mookie1995]

Re: NFL 2009 Thread #3: The Quest for Perfection

you like the RTP call there?

[walrus]

Re: NFL 2009 Thread #3: The Quest for Perfection

Love how Aikman thinks its ok for the Green bay guy to face mask Warner

[Terrierbyassociation]

Re: NFL 2009 Thread #3: The Quest for Perfection

you like the RTP call there?

That was awesome. I too want to be able to tackle defenders into our QB and get it called as a PF against him! How dare you be tackled into our QB!

[bronconick]

Re: NFL 2009 Thread #3: The Quest for Perfection

Larry knocked Woodson over because Charles has a Heisman and Larry got hosed out of his.

[mookie1995]

Re: NFL 2009 Thread #3: The Quest for Perfection

Love how Aikman thinks its ok for the Green bay guy to face mask Warner

"Who am i? What am i doing here?"