Luck or RG3?

[bigmrg74]

Name the last long term great running QB. Then ask how long did he last? Then compare that to a pocket QB.

Well, as long as RGIII doesn't hit his nieghbors dog while driving home, he'll have a longer career than the last great rushing QB.

[The Rube]

Re: Luck or RG3?

Name the last long term great running QB. Then ask how long did he last? Then compare that to a pocket QB.

[Thiessen'sBetter]

I was having this conversation with a couple friends the other day: If you could pick Andrew Luck or Robert Griffin III to start your team with who would you pick? It really is a tough question, but I think I would go with Luck. I think Luck has a higher ceiling because he has better arm strength and accuracy. At some point also, I think teams will be able to adjust to that option RG3 runs. Both are going to be great, and are already really good (I actually think RGIII is having the better rookie year) but I think in the long run Luck will be a tad better. Thoughts?