Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

M&W Hockey Polls

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Fathead
    replied
    Originally posted by Timothy A View Post

    I like nothing burgers, BC is now ranked and UW beat them with the combined score of 17-5.
    Ohio State beat St. Lawrence by a combined 16-1 and St. Lawrence is ranked 8th.

    Leave a comment:


  • HockeyGuy362
    replied
    Originally posted by Timothy A View Post

    I like nothing burgers, BC is now ranked and UW beat them with the combined score of 17-5.
    The polls have been a joke for a long time. I think it was a year or two back, that either BC or BU got swept by a lower ranked opponent and still received a vote for #1. I think the only ones that worry about the rankings are the parents. The kids don't care, at least mine never did, all she cared about was where they were at in the pairwise, to make the tourney.

    Leave a comment:


  • Timothy A
    replied
    Originally posted by FiveHoleFrenzy View Post
    No better "nothing burger" example than to have the supposed 6th ranked aint's come to play the top ranked yuckeyes this past weekend and lose two games by a combined score of 16-1, getting outshot 82-24.
    I like nothing burgers, BC is now ranked and UW beat them with the combined score of 17-5.

    Leave a comment:


  • BowWowWow
    replied
    Looking at the preseason polls since 2006-07, which is as far back as I found, teams ranked 1-3 in those preseason polls have won 11 national championships, while teams ranked 4-6 have won 5 national championships.
    Here is this info organized by the team that won, followed by their preseason rank in the USCHO poll, since the '07 tournament (tourney year in parentheses):
    Wisconsin: 1 ('07), 2 ('09), 5 ('11), 2 ('19), 1 ('21), 3 ('23)
    Minnesota: 4 ('12), 1 ('13), 1 ('15), 1 ('16)
    Clarkson: 3 ('14), 5 ('17), 1 ('18)
    UMD: 5 ('08), 6 ('10)
    OSU: 3 ('22)
    So, the teams outside of the top 3 at any given time are not necessarily nothing burgers. Maybe the group of the top 3 teams has gotten to be a progressively stronger group, though. The WCHA certainly has a great out-of-conference record this season and last season. They have the 3-headed monster - 4-headed if you count UMD?

    I feel as though the rankings as a whole aren't simply about who is going to win the final game of the season, though.

    Leave a comment:


  • Jack McDonald
    replied
    Originally posted by BackyardIce View Post
    I really don’t see this as a big deal. The Women’s poll shows the top 15 which is roughly 1/3 off the 44 D1 teams (slightly more). The Men’s poll is the top 20 which is also roughly 1/3 of the 64 D1 Men’s teams (slightly less actually). So … seems pretty equal to me. The sports that show top 25 have far more D1 teams.
    Sorry you feel this way. This hurts the promotion of M&W Hockey, especially the new programs that are investing thousands, if not millions into M&W Ice Hockey. Not a very good look for USCHO to NOT be Equitable like all other NCAA Sports (Field Hockey, Lacrosse, and more..)

    Leave a comment:


  • FiveHoleFrenzy
    replied
    Originally posted by Timothy A View Post
    If you look at the quality of the teams I think the polls are the right size.
    Agreed...It is not "WRONG" on how the polls are done for what is frankly a niche sport.


    Originally posted by Timothy A View Post
    On the men's side any one of the top 12 teams could win the Natty, while a woman's side honestly only the top three probably can, so what's the point of ranking a bunch of nothing burgers?
    No better "nothing burger" example than to have the supposed 6th ranked aint's come to play the top ranked yuckeyes this past weekend and lose two games by a combined score of 16-1, getting outshot 82-24.



    Leave a comment:


  • Timothy A
    replied
    If you look at the quality of the teams I think the polls are the right size. On the men's side any one of the top 12 teams could win the Natty, while a woman's side honestly only the top three probably can, so what's the point of ranking a bunch of nothing burgers?

    Leave a comment:


  • BackyardIce
    replied
    I really don’t see this as a big deal. The Women’s poll shows the top 15 which is roughly 1/3 off the 44 D1 teams (slightly more). The Men’s poll is the top 20 which is also roughly 1/3 of the 64 D1 Men’s teams (slightly less actually). So … seems pretty equal to me. The sports that show top 25 have far more D1 teams.

    Leave a comment:


  • top cheese
    replied
    Agree 100% Jack!!

    Leave a comment:


  • Jack McDonald
    started a topic M&W Hockey Polls

    M&W Hockey Polls

    Still very, very sad that college hockey/USCHO still is allowed to NOT have and EQUAL number of men's and women's teams in their weekly polls while all other NCAA sports have EQUAL numbers of M&W listed in their polls. This is WRONG for equity and WRONG for the marketing of two great men's and women's sports, especially in the regions that sponsor ice hockey! Sorry to be a pain in he A-- on this but this is WRONG, very, very WRONG. USCHO would generate many, many more "views". Also College D-I M&W Ice Hockey is the "only" NCAA sports that does NOT post a National poll for 25 teams!

Working...
X