Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

By the Numbers: Your All-Time Roster

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Ralph Baer
    replied
    Re: By the Numbers: Your All-Time Roster

    Originally posted by Red Cloud View Post
    I went back and forth between Dallman as 23 but went with Pickett since I limited it to primary numbers - which also eliminated Cutts and Cavosie. There really haven't been that many stellar 23s. I had Duncan further down the list, and hedged on Marsters and Knightley too.
    Going with primary numbers, I agree with you on 27. I would probably pick Rick Smith as 23, for the playoff victory in 1974 over UHN if nothing else. 29 is a real washout, so I would also go to Spadafore on longevity.

    Originally posted by Red Cloud View Post
    EDIT: I almost broke the rules and added Brad Farynuk and Brad Tapper.
    What about Christian Morissette at 36.

    BTW, I am hoping that 16 and 30 change in a few years, perhaps even after this year.
    Last edited by Ralph Baer; 09-04-2009, 07:41 AM. Reason: Eliminated 9 from the last line. It is very unlikely to happen, although I would like it to.

    Leave a comment:


  • wasmania
    replied
    Re: By the Numbers: Your All-Time Roster

    Originally posted by Slap Shot View Post
    1: Robb Stauber
    2: Lou Nanne
    3: Jordan Leopold
    4: Chris McAlpine
    5: Dan Trebil
    6: Charlie Wasley
    7: N Broten over Westrum, Kraft and T. Pederson
    8: Ken Gernander
    9: P Hankinson over Pohl and Chorske
    10: P Martin over P Broten, Skarda, Bell and Goligowski
    11: Christoff over Spehar and Okerlund
    12: Holmgren over Laylin
    13: Ballard over Miller
    14: Butsy Erickson over Cates, Klatt and C Johnson
    15: Tom Vanelli
    16: Todd Richards
    17: Larry Olimb over Chorske (Chorske used 3 diff numbers in 3 years)
    18: Snuggerud over Potulny
    19: Berg over B Hankinson and MacSwain
    20: Mike Crowley
    21: Brian Bonin
    22: Bischoff over Taffe
    23: Zmolek over crazy legs Hirsch
    24: Travis Richards over Koalska
    25: Orth
    26: Vanek over Kessel and Barriball
    27: Bjugstad over Rasmussen
    28: Um...
    29: Stoa over Pagel by a nose
    30: Stolp
    31: Jeff Callinan
    33: John Blue
    I dont remember his number but I would think Pat Micheletti would at least be one of the guys getting overed. And Corey Millen?

    Leave a comment:


  • Red Cloud
    replied
    Re: By the Numbers: Your All-Time Roster

    Originally posted by Ralph Baer View Post
    I'd go with Brian Robins as 5, Pat Hahn as 6, Jim Pope as 11, Dale Watson as 16, Marty Dallman as 23 since I do agree that MacDonald deserves 13, Marc Cavosie as 27, Steve Duncan as 29, and Don Cutts as 30 which he wore as a soph since 0 isn't allowed by the ground rules. I also would take Nate Marsters as 18, but they are impossible to compare.
    I went back and forth between Dallman as 23 but went with Pickett since I limited it to primary numbers - which also eliminated Cutts and Cavosie. There really haven't been that many stellar 23s. I had Duncan further down the list, and hedged on Marsters and Knightley too.

    EDIT: I almost broke the rules and added Brad Farynuk and Brad Tapper.
    Last edited by Red Cloud; 09-04-2009, 07:16 AM.

    Leave a comment:


  • Ralph Baer
    replied
    Re: By the Numbers: Your All-Time Roster

    Originally posted by Red Cloud View Post
    RPI

    1: Daren Puppa
    2: Brian Pothier
    3: Herb LaFontaine
    4: Mike Prpich
    5: Burton Clarkson
    6: Dick Chiarelli
    7: Abbie Moore
    8: Frank Chiarelli
    9: Joe Juneau
    10: Garry Kearns
    11: Brian Ferreira
    12: Adam Oates
    13: Kirk MacDonald
    14: Richard Scammell
    15: John Carter
    16: Larry Landon
    17: Dino Serra
    18: Jerry Knightley
    19: Matt Murley
    20: Joel Laing
    21: Mike Sadeghpour
    22: Mike Dark
    23: Blake Pickett
    24: Don Armstrong
    25: Bryan Tapper
    26: Ken Hammond
    27: Tim Regan
    28: Carson Butterwick
    29: Tim Spadafore
    30: Mike Tamburro
    31: Scott Prekaski
    32: Steve Duncan
    33: Kevin Kurk
    34: Rick Borina
    35: Will Neubert

    I'd go with Brian Robins as 5, Pat Hahn as 6, Jim Pope as 11, Dale Watson as 16, Marty Dallman as 23 since I do agree that MacDonald deserves 13, Marc Cavosie as 27, Steve Duncan as 29, and Don Cutts as 30 which he wore as a soph since 0 isn't allowed by the ground rules. I also would take Nate Marsters as 18, but they are impossible to compare.

    Leave a comment:


  • state of hockey
    replied
    Re: By the Numbers: Your All-Time Roster

    Originally posted by Boosh View Post
    Matt Greene, duh?
    I figure Engelstad will end up at 23 as well.

    Leave a comment:


  • umassfan49
    replied
    Re: By the Numbers: Your All-Time Roster

    Originally posted by state of hockey View Post
    My father and I put our heads together and got this for Minnesota:

    1. Robb Stauber
    2. Lou Nanne
    3. Jordan Leopold
    4. Mike Ramsey
    5. Patrick Westrum
    6. Bill Baker
    7. Rob McClanahan
    8. John Mayasich
    9. Peter Hankinson
    10. Paul Martin
    11. Steve Christoff
    12. Mike Antonovich
    13. Keith Ballard
    14. Neal Broten
    15. Tom Vannelli
    16. Todd Richards
    17. Tom Chorske
    18. Dave Snuggerud
    19. Les Auge
    20. Mike Crowley
    21. Brian Bonin
    22. Jeff Taffe
    23. Tyler Hirsch
    24. Travis Richards
    25. Steve Orth
    26. Thomas Vanek
    27. Scott Bjugstad
    28. Cade Fairchild (only current player)
    29. Ryan Stoa
    30. Jim Jetland
    31. Travis Weber
    32. Dustin Smieja (just to fill the number)
    33. Jon Blue
    34. Kellen Briggs
    35. Steve "Warm Up" DeBus.
    Change #1 to Jeff Frazee and you got it!

    Leave a comment:


  • Boosh
    replied
    Re: By the Numbers: Your All-Time Roster

    Originally posted by The Sicatoka View Post
    A quick try at North Dakota (feel free to continue):

    2:
    Matt Greene, duh?

    Leave a comment:


  • state of hockey
    replied
    Re: By the Numbers: Your All-Time Roster

    Originally posted by ExileOnDaytonStreet View Post
    21: Chris Chelios (D) Tony Granato (F) uh... Tonris Granatelios?
    No, just Chelios.

    Leave a comment:


  • state of hockey
    replied
    Re: By the Numbers: Your All-Time Roster

    My father and I put our heads together and got this for Minnesota:

    1. Robb Stauber
    2. Lou Nanne
    3. Jordan Leopold
    4. Mike Ramsey
    5. Patrick Westrum
    6. Bill Baker
    7. Rob McClanahan
    8. John Mayasich
    9. Peter Hankinson
    10. Paul Martin
    11. Steve Christoff
    12. Mike Antonovich
    13. Keith Ballard
    14. Neal Broten
    15. Tom Vannelli
    16. Todd Richards
    17. Tom Chorske
    18. Dave Snuggerud
    19. Les Auge
    20. Mike Crowley
    21. Brian Bonin
    22. Jeff Taffe
    23. Tyler Hirsch
    24. Travis Richards
    25. Steve Orth
    26. Thomas Vanek
    27. Scott Bjugstad
    28. Cade Fairchild (only current player)
    29. Ryan Stoa
    30. Jim Jetland
    31. Travis Weber
    32. Dustin Smieja (just to fill the number)
    33. Jon Blue
    34. Kellen Briggs
    35. Steve "Warm Up" DeBus.

    Leave a comment:


  • ExileOnDaytonStreet
    replied
    Re: By the Numbers: Your All-Time Roster

    Wisconsin:

    1: Brian Elliott (G)
    2: Bob Suter (D)
    3: Brian Rafalski (D)
    4: Gary Suter (D)
    5: Craig Norwich (D)
    6: Jeff Andriga (D)
    7: John Taft (D)
    8: Joe Pavelski (F)
    9:
    10: Mark Johnson (F)
    11: Jim Johannson (F)
    12: John Johannson (F)
    13:
    14: Tom Gilbert (D)
    15: Dany Heatley (F)
    16: Adam Burish (F)
    17: Mike Eaves (F)
    18:
    19: Tom Sagissor (F)
    20:
    21: Chris Chelios (D) Tony Granato (F) uh... Tonris Granatelios?
    22: Chris Tancill (F)
    23: Steve Tuttle (F)
    24:
    25:
    26: Barry Richter (D)
    27: Steve Reinprecht (F)
    28: Paul Houston (F)
    29: Duane Derksen (G)
    30:
    31: Marc Behrend (G) (sorry Licari)
    32: Bernd Bruckler (G)
    33:
    34:
    35:

    Leave a comment:


  • Slap Shot
    replied
    Re: By the Numbers: Your All-Time Roster

    Originally posted by Koho View Post
    There is room for discussion. 9 Tim Harrer, 6 Bill Baker...see 76-77 roster for that matter for more options. Broten wore 14 one year too, cause some hack named Rob McClanahan wore 7 that year. I'd consider Aaron Broten over Martin too (I'm not sure Neal was better than him the year he won the Hobey.) 8 Corey Millen. 19 DeMarchi? And what numbers were Mariucci and Mayasich?
    Yeah, I knew that I'd forget a few and those are some great players that deserve consideration. Aaron was perhaps better the year Neal won the Hobey but they weren't up against each other. I did my list more for fun and for the memories than anything and thought it would be good to get some back and forth going on the concept.

    Leave a comment:


  • Red Cloud
    replied
    Re: By the Numbers: Your All-Time Roster

    Originally posted by burgie12 View Post
    I like your style
    Yeah, well it was Will or Tim Camitta. Same job, only one was here for four years. Easy choice.

    Leave a comment:


  • state of hockey
    replied
    Re: By the Numbers: Your All-Time Roster

    Originally posted by Koho View Post
    There is room for discussion. 9 Tim Harrer, 6 Bill Baker...see 76-77 roster for that matter for more options. Broten wore 14 one year too, cause some hack named Rob McClanahan wore 7 that year. I'd consider Aaron Broten over Martin too (I'm not sure Neal was better than him the year he won the Hobey.) 8 Corey Millen. 19 DeMarchi? And what numbers were Mariucci and Mayasich?
    Mayasich was number 8, which is now retired because of him.

    Leave a comment:


  • burgie12
    replied
    Re: By the Numbers: Your All-Time Roster

    Originally posted by Red Cloud View Post
    RPI

    35: Will Neubert
    I like your style

    Leave a comment:


  • Red Cloud
    replied
    Re: By the Numbers: Your All-Time Roster

    RPI

    1: Daren Puppa
    2: Brian Pothier
    3: Herb LaFontaine
    4: Mike Prpich
    5: Burton Clarkson
    6: Dick Chiarelli
    7: Abbie Moore
    8: Frank Chiarelli
    9: Joe Juneau
    10: Garry Kearns
    11: Brian Ferreira
    12: Adam Oates
    13: Kirk MacDonald
    14: Richard Scammell
    15: John Carter
    16: Larry Landon
    17: Dino Serra
    18: Jerry Knightley
    19: Matt Murley
    20: Joel Laing
    21: Mike Sadeghpour
    22: Mike Dark
    23: Blake Pickett
    24: Don Armstrong
    25: Bryan Tapper
    26: Ken Hammond
    27: Tim Regan
    28: Carson Butterwick
    29: Tim Spadafore
    30: Mike Tamburro
    31: Scott Prekaski
    32: Steve Duncan
    33: Kevin Kurk
    34: Rick Borina
    35: Will Neubert

    Leave a comment:

Working...
X