Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

By the Numbers: Your All-Time Roster

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • #16
    Re: By the Numbers: Your All-Time Roster

    Originally posted by Ralph Baer View Post
    I'd go with Brian Robins as 5, Pat Hahn as 6, Jim Pope as 11, Dale Watson as 16, Marty Dallman as 23 since I do agree that MacDonald deserves 13, Marc Cavosie as 27, Steve Duncan as 29, and Don Cutts as 30 which he wore as a soph since 0 isn't allowed by the ground rules. I also would take Nate Marsters as 18, but they are impossible to compare.
    I went back and forth between Dallman as 23 but went with Pickett since I limited it to primary numbers - which also eliminated Cutts and Cavosie. There really haven't been that many stellar 23s. I had Duncan further down the list, and hedged on Marsters and Knightley too.

    EDIT: I almost broke the rules and added Brad Farynuk and Brad Tapper.
    Last edited by Red Cloud; 09-04-2009, 08:16 AM.
    Keep an open mind. Just don't be so open-minded that your brain falls out.

    Comment


    • #17
      Re: By the Numbers: Your All-Time Roster

      Originally posted by Slap Shot View Post
      1: Robb Stauber
      2: Lou Nanne
      3: Jordan Leopold
      4: Chris McAlpine
      5: Dan Trebil
      6: Charlie Wasley
      7: N Broten over Westrum, Kraft and T. Pederson
      8: Ken Gernander
      9: P Hankinson over Pohl and Chorske
      10: P Martin over P Broten, Skarda, Bell and Goligowski
      11: Christoff over Spehar and Okerlund
      12: Holmgren over Laylin
      13: Ballard over Miller
      14: Butsy Erickson over Cates, Klatt and C Johnson
      15: Tom Vanelli
      16: Todd Richards
      17: Larry Olimb over Chorske (Chorske used 3 diff numbers in 3 years)
      18: Snuggerud over Potulny
      19: Berg over B Hankinson and MacSwain
      20: Mike Crowley
      21: Brian Bonin
      22: Bischoff over Taffe
      23: Zmolek over crazy legs Hirsch
      24: Travis Richards over Koalska
      25: Orth
      26: Vanek over Kessel and Barriball
      27: Bjugstad over Rasmussen
      28: Um...
      29: Stoa over Pagel by a nose
      30: Stolp
      31: Jeff Callinan
      33: John Blue
      I dont remember his number but I would think Pat Micheletti would at least be one of the guys getting overed. And Corey Millen?

      Comment


      • #18
        Re: By the Numbers: Your All-Time Roster

        Originally posted by Red Cloud View Post
        I went back and forth between Dallman as 23 but went with Pickett since I limited it to primary numbers - which also eliminated Cutts and Cavosie. There really haven't been that many stellar 23s. I had Duncan further down the list, and hedged on Marsters and Knightley too.
        Going with primary numbers, I agree with you on 27. I would probably pick Rick Smith as 23, for the playoff victory in 1974 over UHN if nothing else. 29 is a real washout, so I would also go to Spadafore on longevity.

        Originally posted by Red Cloud View Post
        EDIT: I almost broke the rules and added Brad Farynuk and Brad Tapper.
        What about Christian Morissette at 36.

        BTW, I am hoping that 16 and 30 change in a few years, perhaps even after this year.
        Last edited by Ralph Baer; 09-04-2009, 08:41 AM. Reason: Eliminated 9 from the last line. It is very unlikely to happen, although I would like it to.
        sigpic

        Let's Go 'Tute!

        Maxed out at 2,147,483,647 at 10:00 AM EDT 9/17/07.

        2012 Poser Of The Year

        Comment


        • #19
          Re: By the Numbers: Your All-Time Roster

          ...for your defending Triple Crown Champion Terriers of Boston University!!!


          1: Jack Ferreira
          2: Bob Brown (close 2nd Peter Brown)
          3: Tony Amonte (c2 Chris O'Sullivan)
          4: Phil Von Stefenelli
          5: Tom Poti
          6: Dick Kelley
          7: David Van der Gulik
          8: Terry Meagher
          9: Ed Lowney (c2 Steve Stirling)
          10: Vic Stanfield
          11: Scott Lachance
          12: Mike Grier (c2 John Danby)
          13: Ed Ronan
          14: Joe Sacco (c2 Larry Davenport)
          15: Rick Meagher (c2 Shawn McEachern)
          16: David Sacco (c2 Peter MacArthur)
          17: Jack Garrity (Tc2 OC, Jay Pandolfo, Dick Rodenheiser, Bob Marquis)
          18: Chris Drury (c2 Herb Wakabayashi)
          19: John Cullen
          20: Craig Sanders
          21: Mike Eruzione
          22:
          23: Dick Lamby
          24: Mike Sullivan
          25: Scott Young
          26: Jon Coleman
          27: Bryan Miller
          28: Fabulous Freddy Meyer
          29: Rick DiPietro
          30: Jim Craig
          31: Sean Fields
          33: Colin Wilson
          35: Cleon Daskalakis
          36: John Curry
          97: Matt Gilroy
          a legend and an out of work bum look a lot alike, daddy.

          Comment


          • #20
            Re: By the Numbers: Your All-Time Roster

            Originally posted by mookie1995 View Post
            ...for your defending Triple Crown Champion Terriers of Boston University!!!


            1: Jack Ferreira
            2: Bob Brown (close 2nd Peter Brown)
            3: Tony Amonte (c2 Chris O'Sullivan)
            4: Phil Von Stefenelli
            5: Tom Poti
            6: Dick Kelley
            7: David Van der Gulik
            8: Terry Meagher
            9: Ed Lowney (c2 Steve Stirling)
            10: Vic Stanfield
            11: Scott Lachance
            12: Mike Grier (c2 John Danby)
            13: Ed Ronan
            14: Joe Sacco (c2 Larry Davenport)
            15: Rick Meagher (c2 Shawn McEachern)
            16: David Sacco (c2 Peter MacArthur)
            17: Jack Garrity (Tc2 OC, Jay Pandolfo, Dick Rodenheiser, Bob Marquis)
            18: Chris Drury (c2 Herb Wakabayashi)
            19: John Cullen
            20: Craig Sanders
            21: Mike Eruzione
            22: Matt Wright - he of the "last Beanpot goal in the Garden and last goal in a college hockey game at the Garden (Hockey East tourney)"
            23: Dick Lamby
            24: Mike Sullivan
            25: Scott Young
            26: Jon Coleman
            27: Bryan Miller
            28: Fabulous Freddy Meyer
            29: Rick DiPietro
            30: Jim Craig
            31: Sean Fields
            33: Colin Wilson
            35: Cleon Daskalakis
            36: John Curry
            97: Matt Gilroy


            FYP

            Comment


            • #21
              Re: By the Numbers: Your All-Time Roster

              Originally posted by wasmania View Post
              I dont remember his number but I would think Pat Micheletti would at least be one of the guys getting overed. And Corey Millen?
              Loved both those guys and they crossed my mind (as well as others I missed like Mariucci, Mayasich, Ramsey, Harrer...) during the creation of the list, but in the end it was hard to remember if everyone was included given how many great players skated for the U.
              Last edited by Slap Shot; 09-04-2009, 11:47 AM.

              Comment


              • #22
                Re: By the Numbers: Your All-Time Roster

                No Travis Roy as a second choice for #24?
                Keep an open mind. Just don't be so open-minded that your brain falls out.

                Comment


                • #23
                  Re: By the Numbers: Your All-Time Roster

                  For Notre Dame:

                  1. Jordan Pearce
                  2. Bill Nyrop
                  3. Jim Brown
                  4. Jeff Brownschidle
                  5. Mark Eaton
                  6. Greg Meredith
                  7. Jack Brownschidle
                  8. Brian Walsh
                  9. Bill Rothstein
                  10A. Phil Wittliff
                  10B. Kirt Bjork
                  11A. Ian Williams
                  11B. Erik Condra
                  12. Kevin Nugent
                  13. Brett Lebda
                  14. Brock Sheahan
                  15A. Eddie Bumbacco
                  15B. Dave Poulin
                  16. Brian Urick
                  17. Ted Weltzin
                  18. Rob Globke
                  19. Jamie Ling
                  20A. Alex Pirus
                  20B. John Noble
                  21. Clark Hamilton
                  22. Mike McNeill
                  23. John Schmidt
                  24.
                  25. Benoit Cotnoir
                  26.
                  27.
                  28.
                  29. Morgan Cey
                  30. David Brown
                  "Hockey is the only tribe I belong to." --Jack Falla

                  "Why, as a matter of fact, I suggested starting a hockey program to Father Callahan, our president. He was downright interested until we came to the use of sticks, and then he threw up his hands. He said, 'No, that game is not for our University. Notre Dame will never endorse any game that puts a club in the hands of an Irishman.' " -- Knute Rockne: All American

                  Comment


                  • #24
                    Re: By the Numbers: Your All-Time Roster

                    Denver:

                    1: Ron Grahame over George Kirkwood (Both were AAs, but Ronny went on to greater fame)
                    2: Keith Magnuson - Two time AA, two time NCAA Champ, Greatest Pioneer Ever
                    3: George Konik -AA, good early 60s player
                    4: Brett Skinner over Chris Butler and Craig Redmond (Skinner won two NCAA crowns and was an AA. Redmond was the best frosh I ever saw in a DU but only stayed a year, while Butler was an AA, but was not the leader Skinner was)
                    5: Marty Howe - Two time AA in ealry 60s
                    6: Grant Munro - AA in early 60s
                    7: Glenn Anderson - Only stayed a year in 79. Future NHL hall of Famer.
                    8: Cal Sandbeck - Steady 70s player
                    9: Gabe Gauthier over Kevin Dineen, Dwight Mathiasen or Bill Masterton (Tough one - these guys were all great. Gauthier was an AA and scored the biggest goal in DU history in 04, , so he gets the nod over Dineen (hardest working DU player ever), Mathiasen (big stats and an AA in 1986 and Masterton (an easlry 60s AA who later became famous for being the only player to die in an NHL game in 1968
                    10: Cliff Korroll - Key player on two NC teams in late 60s, went on to NHL career
                    11: Jerry Walker -AA - Great scorer on DU's early 60s dynasty
                    12: Dallas Gaume -Hobey Finalist, AA and All time scoring leader at DU in mid 80s
                    13: Rich Preston - 70s player who later went on to the NHL
                    14: Jim Wiste over Dave Shields (Wiste was a two-time AA, pro player and gets points for owning the Campus Lounge (a great hockey bar), Shields was a Hobey Finalist)
                    15: Eddie Miller over John McMillan and Peter McNab (Miller was DU's first AA)
                    16: George Morrison - Two time AA in late 60s NC teams
                    17: Craig Patrick over Daryn McBride (Patrick was the more valuable captain on two NC teams, although McBride was an AA)
                    18: Ed Cristofoli - DU Iron man in late 80s, later played for Montreal in NHL
                    19: Connor James - Heart and Soul player on DU's 2004 title team
                    20: Paul Comrie - AA - Big stats, big head
                    21: Ryan Caldwell over Tyler Bozak. Caldwell was an AA.
                    22: Ken Berry - Talented, went on to long pro career in 80s
                    23: Marty Steinley - Above average player on high scoring, no defense DU teams in early 80s
                    24: Adam Berkhoel - Won an NC in 2004
                    25: Matt Carle - Hobey Baker Winner - only one in Denver history in 06
                    26: Paul Stastny - Later wore 11. Was an AA in 06, and key player on 05 NC team.
                    27: Matt Laatsch - Not so much for his talent, but for his heart and leadership as captain i 05
                    28: Patrick Wiercioch - not much competition at this number, but a great player already
                    29: Peter Mannino - Should have been an AA, but got an NC instead as a frosh in 05
                    30: Chris Olson - Was an AA back in 1986
                    31: Wade Dubielewicz - Probably the greatest DU goalie in terms of stats
                    33: Sinue Wallinheimo - Gets in for his wild antics (mid 90s)
                    34: Ben Henrich - Not much competition at this number
                    39: Brock Trotter - not a traditional number but a deserving player (07)
                    Last edited by Puck Swami; 09-04-2009, 01:37 PM.

                    Comment


                    • #25
                      Re: By the Numbers: Your All-Time Roster

                      My take on Notre Dame. A couple of #s have few players represented and my choices may have been for intangibles/leadership. My number choices are pretty similar to JJfPs, but I'll go with the numbers the player wore most frequently. For instance, I believe Brett Lebda was #10 as a frosh, but #13 his final 3 years at Notre Dame.

                      1. Jordan Pearce
                      2. Bill Nyrop
                      3. Jim Brown
                      4. Jeff Brownshidle
                      5. Ian Williams
                      6. Greg Meredith
                      7. Jack Brownshidle
                      8. Ben Simon
                      9. Don Fairholm
                      10. Kirt Bjork
                      11. Erik Condra (A)
                      12. Kevin Nugent
                      13. Brett Lebda
                      14. Tom Michalek
                      15. Dave Poulin (A)
                      16. Brian Walsh
                      17. Tim Harberts
                      18. Rob Globke
                      19. Jamie Ling
                      20. Alex Pirus
                      21. Clark Hamilton
                      22. Calle Ridderwall
                      23. Mark Van Guilder
                      24. Tom Galvin
                      25. Benoit Cotnoir
                      26. T.J. Jindra (C)
                      27. Dan Sawyer (only player on list who played strictly in the club/D1 indy era)
                      28. Ian Cole
                      29. Morgan Cey
                      30. David Brown

                      *31 Forrest Karr
                      *33 Garrett Regan

                      *only 3 players wore either number

                      Comment


                      • #26
                        Re: By the Numbers: Your All-Time Roster

                        Originally posted by The Sicatoka View Post
                        North Dakota (feel free to continue):

                        1: Karl Goehring (Jordan Parise)
                        2: Craig Ludgwig (Curtis Murphy, Matt Greene, Dave Hakstol)
                        3: James Patrick (Murray Baron)
                        4: Ian Kidd (Lee Goren, David Hale, Taylor Chorney)
                        5: Jason Blake (Scott Sandelin, David Lundbohm, Chay Genoway)
                        6: Andy Schneider
                        7: TJ Oshie (Brad Bombardir, Bucks Bochenski, Travis Roche, Hrkac also wore)
                        8: Mike Commodore (Dave Tippett, Kevin Hoogsteen)
                        9: Jon Toews
                        10: Bryan Lundbohm
                        11: Zach Parise (Dixon Ward, Rastislov Spirko)
                        12: Terry Casey (RIP, and the reason #12 won't be worn at UND again)
                        13: Mitch Vig
                        14: Ben Cherski (Brady Murray)
                        15: Travis Zajac (James Archibald, Jesse Bull)
                        16: Reg Morelli (Jay Panzer, Ryan Duncan, Tarek Howard, Kevin Spiewak)
                        17: Jeff Panzer
                        18: Drew Stafford (Tim O'Keefe, David Hoogsteen, Tim Skarperud)
                        19: Jeff Ulmer (Ryan Bayda, Mike Prpich)
                        20: Bob Joyce
                        21: Tony Hrkac
                        22: Cary Eades
                        23: Ralph
                        24: Chris Porter (Brad Defauw, Dane Jackson)
                        25: Phil Sykes (Ryan Hale)
                        26: Ryan Johnson (Jason Notermann)
                        27: Matt Smaby
                        28: Robbie Bina
                        29: Ed Belfour (Chris VandeVelde)
                        30: Darren Jensen
                        31: Jeff Lembke
                        32: Daniel McKinnon
                        33:
                        34: JP Lamoureux (he wore it at UND for at least a season)
                        35: Jon Casey (Toby Kvalevog)
                        here are my thoughts on it...probably too biased towards the last few decades though.
                        North Dakota
                        National Champions: 1959, 1963, 1980, 1982, 1987, 1997, 2000, 2016

                        Comment


                        • #27
                          Re: By the Numbers: Your All-Time Roster

                          Originally posted by Slap Shot View Post
                          Loved both those guys and they crossed my mind (as well as others I missed like Mariucci, Mayasich, Ramsey, Harrer...) during the creation of the list, but in the end it was hard to remember if everyone was included given how many great players skated for the U.
                          It is tough! I wanted to fit Micheletti and Harrer in, but there were just someone I think is better than them on that number. The only reason I have Broten on 14 is so I could put in McClanahan. It was basically which two out of the three of Neal Broten, Butsy Erickson, and Rob McClanahan do you want on the list? There really isn't a wrong answer, either.
                          the state of hockey is good

                          Comment


                          • #28
                            Re: By the Numbers: Your All-Time Roster

                            Originally posted by state of hockey View Post
                            It is tough! I wanted to fit Micheletti and Harrer in, but there were just someone I think is better than them on that number. The only reason I have Broten on 14 is so I could put in McClanahan. It was basically which two out of the three of Neal Broten, Butsy Erickson, and Rob McClanahan do you want on the list? There really isn't a wrong answer, either.
                            I think I would lean towards Harrer. 82 points his senior year including 53 goals in 41 games!? He was a goal scoring machine. Not that P. Hankinson wasn't a key player on his teams.

                            Also, someone considerably less lazy than me should put together a Gopher list like Swami's, with notes on each player for the uninformed.

                            I'd love to see Glen Sonmor and Louie put together a list together, since they've seen more years than most of us.

                            Comment


                            • #29
                              Re: By the Numbers: Your All-Time Roster

                              Originally posted by Koho View Post
                              I think I would lean towards Harrer. 82 points his senior year including 53 goals in 41 games!? He was a goal scoring machine. Not that P. Hankinson wasn't a key player on his teams.
                              Harrer should probably be on there. My dad and I were kind of going off of the people that did a ton or fit key roles for the teams that did the most.

                              AU-GE!
                              the state of hockey is good

                              Comment


                              • #30
                                Re: By the Numbers: Your All-Time Roster

                                Originally posted by Fighting Sioux 23 View Post
                                here are my thoughts on it...probably too biased towards the last few decades though.
                                Zajac over Archie?

                                Comment

                                Working...
                                X