Originally posted by joecct
View Post
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
Comparison of Jr. Hockey Leagues
Collapse
X
-
Re: Comparison of Jr. Hockey Leagues
-
Re: Comparison of Jr. Hockey Leagues
Originally posted by joecct View PostTo distinguish themselves from the NAHL. The USHL and NAHL used to play for US Junior hockey supremacy. Then the USHL decided that they were too good and stopped playing the NAHL. So USA came up with the Tier system to distinguish the USHL from the rest of the great unwashed.
If you think I am very cynical about USA Hockey, you're right.
Leave a comment:
-
Re: Comparison of Jr. Hockey Leagues
Originally posted by davyd83 View PostBack then, the USHL was Tier II, the same as the BCHL. The USHL is now Tier I.
If you think I am very cynical about USA Hockey, you're right.
Leave a comment:
-
Re: Comparison of Jr. Hockey Leagues
Originally posted by Ralph Baer View PostI don't think that the BCHL and AJHL have declined as much as the USHL has improved. OTOH, it does seem that the OJHL has declined in comparison to the western Tier II leagues.
Cripe I remember a time when just about every major college program had OJHL representation and some of the better programs relied exclusively on the league for recruiting top notch talent. Today, most OPJHL grads can be found at the smaller schools and are often the non-scholarship players.
Leave a comment:
-
Re: Comparison of Jr. Hockey Leagues
Originally posted by Split-N View PostThis!
Truth is, there are far too many Jr. hockey "franchises" that are nothing more than moneymaking schemes that feed on the unrealistic dreams of pampered kids and gullible parents. The only real barrier to entry is the parent's checkbook. The net result is that high school hockey in many places has been emasculated while U16 youth hockey gets weakened by Jr. leagues willing (even anxious) to take "underage" players. And, unlike Canada, USA Hockey seems powerless to do anything about it.
Leave a comment:
-
Re: Comparison of Jr. Hockey Leagues
Originally posted by jnacc View PostCanadian Junior A hockey (Tier II) has seen a dramatic decline in quality over the past 10 to 15 years. 15 years ago the BCHL and AJHL were every bit as good as the USHL, the BCHL perhaps even better. The OJHL was easily on par with the NAHL as was the eastern based MJHL...today the BCHL would be hard pressed to field 4 teams that would be competitive in the USHL while leagues like the OJHL are a clear step below that of the NAHL.
The CHL, on the other hand, is relatively stronger than they were a decade or so ago. A top USHL club would fare well against a low-end CHL team but would have a very very difficult time against an average to good CHL team. No USHL team is at a level where they could be remotely competitive in a Memorial Cup tournament.
Leave a comment:
-
Re: Comparison of Jr. Hockey Leagues
Originally posted by joecct View PostForget all (and I mean all) of the Eastern US junior leagues. There are too many teams with almost no barriers to entry, and extremely watered down talent.
Truth is, there are far too many Jr. hockey "franchises" that are nothing more than moneymaking schemes that feed on the unrealistic dreams of pampered kids and gullible parents. The only real barrier to entry is the parent's checkbook. The net result is that high school hockey in many places has been emasculated while U16 youth hockey gets weakened by Jr. leagues willing (even anxious) to take "underage" players. And, unlike Canada, USA Hockey seems powerless to do anything about it.Last edited by Split-N; 05-27-2014, 11:03 AM.
Leave a comment:
-
Re: Comparison of Jr. Hockey Leagues
Originally posted by Ralph Baer View PostI don't think that the BCHL and AJHL have declined as much as the USHL has improved. OTOH, it does seem that the OJHL has declined in comparison to the western Tier II leagues.
Leave a comment:
-
Re: Comparison of Jr. Hockey Leagues
Originally posted by jnacc View PostCanadian Junior A hockey (Tier II) has seen a dramatic decline in quality over the past 10 to 15 years. 15 years ago the BCHL and AJHL were every bit as good as the USHL, the BCHL perhaps even better. The OJHL was easily on par with the NAHL as was the eastern based MJHL...today the BCHL would be hard pressed to field 4 teams that would be competitive in the USHL while leagues like the OJHL are a clear step below that of the NAHL.
The CHL, on the other hand, is relatively stronger than they were a decade or so ago. A top USHL club would fare well against a low-end CHL team but would have a very very difficult time against an average to good CHL team. No USHL team is at a level where they could be remotely competitive in a Memorial Cup tournament.
Leave a comment:
-
Re: Comparison of Jr. Hockey Leagues
Canadian Junior A hockey (Tier II) has seen a dramatic decline in quality over the past 10 to 15 years. 15 years ago the BCHL and AJHL were every bit as good as the USHL, the BCHL perhaps even better. The OJHL was easily on par with the NAHL as was the eastern based MJHL...today the BCHL would be hard pressed to field 4 teams that would be competitive in the USHL while leagues like the OJHL are a clear step below that of the NAHL.
The CHL, on the other hand, is relatively stronger than they were a decade or so ago. A top USHL club would fare well against a low-end CHL team but would have a very very difficult time against an average to good CHL team. No USHL team is at a level where they could be remotely competitive in a Memorial Cup tournament.
Leave a comment:
-
Re: Comparison of Jr. Hockey Leagues
Originally posted by Bonin21 View PostAnd even the best USHL teams probably wouldn't hang with the better CHL teams. Top few USHL vs. lower half CHL might be interesting.
Leave a comment:
-
Re: Comparison of Jr. Hockey Leagues
Forget all (and I mean all) of the Eastern US junior leagues. There are too many teams with almost no barriers to entry, and extremely watered down talent.
Leave a comment:
-
Re: Comparison of Jr. Hockey Leagues
Originally posted by Ralph Baer View PostThe USHL is the only US league which would have a chance.
Leave a comment:
-
Re: Comparison of Jr. Hockey Leagues
Originally posted by ExHockeyguy View PostAfter having recently watched the Canadian Major Jr. (Memorial Cup) championships on NHL Network; plus the USHL and NAHL championships on FastHockey, etc. and the IIHF World Jr. Championships I got to thinking again about the competitiveness between these leagues. I remember back in the late 70's, early 80's when "Hockey Night in Boston" was real big promoting Massachusetts High School hockey and the fabled Darby Yeager and Lance Lofaro would put together special tournaments. One was the Mass-Minn challenge which was very successful in terms of publicity. Another was a Series between the QMJHL All-Stars and a select group of high school seniors and college Division 1 freshmen. It was a series of games filled with fights, sticks and brutal hockey where the QMJHL destroyed the US contingent (I could be wrong but that's how I remember it). Steve Kasper (later of the Boston Bruins) I believe was on the QMJHL team.
So what I'm getting at is - what do you think the outcomes would be between games involving OHL, QMJHL and WHL teams with their US counterparts such as the USHL, NAHL or USPHL? We've all seen from an international standpoint (i.e. world championships) that most any country can put together 20 high quality skaters...but what about the totality of players in each league? Remember back when hockey East started and there was the interlocking schedule between HE and the WCHA? That was great hockey.
Just wondering as the summer begins...
Leave a comment:
Leave a comment: