SCSU @ UND - November 13-14

[scsutommyboy]

Re: SCSU @ UND - November 13-14

no, no you can't. A point man dumps the puck in...you can't hit him 10 seconds later and say oh he had the puck. And if you're watching Marvin, he's keying up on him. He clearly had intent to hit Genoway and my guess is with intent to injure. It was a scumbag hit and a yearlong suspension should be in order.

First of all check the rules buddy. Of course you can't check him 10 seconds later, but that isn't what happend here. You clearly are clueless so I am done debating this with you.

[The Rube]

Re: SCSU @ UND - November 13-14

Question for you. Have you ever played hockey? I would think if you have you would see how these things happen. I agree players need to play more in control and when they don't they have to pay the price by sitting out. However, in the heat of the battle and when you go to hit a guy at full speed these things happen sometime and your arms get up to high. I guarantee not every time these type of hits happen the guy is trying to hurt the other guy. Marvin has never been a dirty player in the past, so I think he should get he benefit of the doubt. Like I said before it doesn't make what he did right, but there is a difference between playing hard and a little careless and trying to hurt someone.

I know for a fact that MNS has played hockey, including HS hockey if I am not mistaken, at a non-crappy HS, no less.

This particular hit was maybe not 100% to injure, but IMO I think Marvin wanted to ring his bell a little.

[brianvf]

Re: SCSU @ UND - November 13-14

Yearlong?
Nice overreaction.

Sloe is the king of the over reaction.

Question for you. Have you ever played hockey?

You should have just brought up his post count and lost the verbal argument that way instead.

[Dirty]

Re: SCSU @ UND - November 13-14

First of all check the rules buddy. Of course you can't check him 10 seconds later, but that isn't what happend here. You clearly are clueless so I am done debating this with you.

This stance doesn't make sense. You continually debate things with FTLT.

[scsutommyboy]

Re: SCSU @ UND - November 13-14

Where did I say it wasn't against the rules to hit him high?
I'm just saying I don't believe you can argue it was automatically intent to injure.

I didn't say you did. I actually agreed with you for once.

[scsutommyboy]

Re: SCSU @ UND - November 13-14

I know for a fact that MNS has played hockey, including HS hockey if I am not mistaken, at a non-crappy HS, no less.

This particular hit was maybe not 100% to injure, but IMO I think Marvin wanted to ring his bell a little.

Then he needs to take his UND glasses off and realize it's possible he wasn't trying to hurt him. It's easy for a guy to hit someone high when you have 5 inches on them especially when they are leaning against the boards.

[The Rube]

Re: SCSU @ UND - November 13-14

Sloe is the king of the over reaction.



You should have just brought up his post count and lost the verbal argument that way instead.

True, and true.

1 game is fair, I guess. I would've said 2 games, if only for the attention those kinds of hits have been given in the last couple of years.

And scsutommy: take off your beer goggles and realize that it looked like intent to injure. We'll never know for sure, but it looked like it.

[scsutommyboy]

Re: SCSU @ UND - November 13-14

This stance doesn't make sense. You continually debate things with FTLT.

I do that just to pi$s her off.

[Dirty]

Re: SCSU @ UND - November 13-14

I do that just to pi$s her off.

Geist might shoot you though, so you should probably just let him remain angry.

[Happy]

Re: SCSU @ UND - November 13-14

Nothing like a good "UND whining about the Refs again" fest to make everyone else smile. Has UND ever lost a single game when it wasn't the refs fault? I didn't think so.

[Dirty]

Re: SCSU @ UND - November 13-14

Nothing like a good "UND whining about the Refs again" fest to make everyone else smile. Has UND ever lost a single game when it wasn't the refs fault? I didn't think so.

Tonight.

[Sloe Gin]

Re: SCSU @ UND - November 13-14

Sloe is the king of the over reaction.

I am?

Geist might shoot you though, so you should probably just let him remain angry.

probably

[Dude Love]

Re: SCSU @ UND - November 13-14

no, no you can't. A point man dumps the puck in...you can't hit him 10 seconds later and say oh he had the puck. And if you're watching Marvin, he's keying up on him. He clearly had intent to hit Genoway and my guess is with intent to injure. It was a scumbag hit and a yearlong suspension should be in order.

C'mon, Sand Vag...that's a little extreme. If this was the NHL, he'd have gotten maybe 2 games depending on how Colin Campbell felt that day. You're starting to sound like a Gopher fan with all the crying you do about officials and teams being out to get you.

[Plante26]

Re: SCSU @ UND - November 13-14

C'mon, Sand Vag...that's a little extreme. If this was the NHL, he'd have gotten maybe 2 games depending on how Colin Campbell felt that day. You're starting to sound like a Gopher fan with all the crying you do about officials and teams being out to get you.

I just saw the hit on a blog, and it looked pretty deliberate. Marvin made no attempt to hit Genoway from the side--he lined him him and drove him facefirst into the glass. I wouldn't be surprised to see Marvin get a couple more games from the WCHA or SCSU.

[Dude Love]

Re: SCSU @ UND - November 13-14

I just saw the hit on a blog, and it looked pretty deliberate. Marvin made no attempt to hit Genoway from the side--he lined him him and drove him facefirst into the glass. I wouldn't be surprised to see Marvin get a couple more games from the WCHA or SCSU.

I'm gonna say that tonight was the only game he'll be suspended for.